Contents8
Traditional hiring often focuses on how candidates present themselves, the technical phrases in their CVs and the interviewer’s immediate personal affinity. Research in industrial and organizational psychology shows that unstructured, intuitive interviews of this kind are weak predictors of job performance. Competency-based interviews, by contrast, rest on the principle that a candidate’s concrete past behaviour is one of the most reliable predictors of future success.
The well-known meta-analysis by Schmidt and Hunter (1998) reported a validity coefficient of 0.51 for structured interviews in predicting job performance, clearly above unstructured interviews. Anchoring the scoring to observable behaviours with Behaviourally Anchored Rating Scales (BARS) makes assessment even more consistent across interviewers. This guide shows how to build that structure step by step.
What is a competency-based interview?
A competency-based interview is a structured assessment method that measures a candidate’s behavioural, cognitive and interpersonal competencies for a role through their past experience, using the same questions and criteria for every candidate.
| Interview type | How decisions are made | Typical risks |
|---|---|---|
| Unstructured | Intuition, immediate affinity and “gut feeling” | Halo effect, confirmation bias, unfair comparisons between candidates |
| Semi-structured | Candidate stories explored in a flexible conversation | Subjectivity persists; different candidates get different questions |
| Structured, competency-based | The same competency questions for all candidates, scored against shared criteria | Potential of candidates without direct experience may be overlooked |
| Structured with BARS | Answers matched to concrete, observable behavioural anchors | Building the scales takes time and needs regular updates as roles change |
Competency modeling: Korn Ferry and SHRM
Competency modeling divides the critical behaviours expected in a role into measurable categories, so that hiring, development and performance management use the same language. Two widely used frameworks are the SHRM Competency Model and the Korn Ferry Leadership Architect (KFLA).
The SHRM approach treats HR professionals as business partners who shape strategy, not only administer processes; its competencies are grouped into leadership, interpersonal and business clusters aligned with organizational goals. KFLA classifies 38 behavioural competencies under four factors: Thought, Results, People and Self. For each competency, it gives a developmental difficulty rating from 1 (easiest) to 5 (most difficult), showing how much time and effort it takes to build that competency on the job.
| KFLA factor | Competency | Definition | Difficulty |
|---|---|---|---|
| Thought | Strategic Mindset | Anticipating future possibilities and turning them into competitive strategies | 5 |
| Thought | Decision Quality | Making sound, timely decisions that keep the organization moving | 2 |
| Results | Ensures Accountability | Making sure that one’s own and others’ commitments are met | 2 |
| Results | Optimizes Work Processes | Designing effective, efficient processes with a focus on continuous improvement | 3 |
| People | Collaborates | Building partnerships across the organization to reach shared goals | 2 |
| People | Builds Effective Teams | Combining diverse talents and perspectives into strong teams | 5 |
| Self | Manages Ambiguity | Working effectively when matters are unclear and the way forward is uncertain | 5 |
For leadership roles in particular, people-focused competencies such as building effective teams, instilling trust and developing talent should be assessed explicitly in the interview, because they shape engagement and retention in the teams the person will lead.
Behaviourally Anchored Rating Scales (BARS)
BARS score interview answers by matching them with concrete, observable behavioural anchors defined in advance through job analysis, instead of relying on subjective impressions. They reduce common rater errors such as leniency. Building a BARS framework typically involves five steps:
- Set up a governance team: Secure senior management support so the work is aligned with strategy and does not remain an HR-only initiative.
- Identify subject matter experts: Form a first expert group of experienced employees and managers who know the role best.
- Collect critical incidents: Experts document behaviours in the role that were exceptionally effective and exceptionally ineffective.
- Define performance dimensions: Group the collected behaviours under shared competency dimensions such as collaboration, conflict management or customer focus.
- Retranslate and scale: A second, independent expert group re-assigns the behaviours to dimensions and rates each one from 1 to 5, finalizing the anchors.
Example BARS rubric: Collaboration
| Score | Level | Behavioural anchors |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Below standard | Resists teamwork; belittles other departments’ views; avoids sharing information to pursue individual goals. |
| 2 | Developing | Collaborates reluctantly and only when required; tends to dominate communication and disregard others’ ideas. |
| 3 | Meets standard | Communicates respectfully; takes responsibility in shared tasks; aligns with constructive joint decisions in conflict. |
| 4 | Exceeds standard | Actively involves different perspectives and departments; shares experience and improves shared processes. |
| 5 | Role model | Builds cross-functional collaboration across the organization; mediates tense interdepartmental conflicts and develops solutions. |
Example BARS rubric: Initiative and proactive problem-solving
| Score | Level | Behavioural anchors |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Below standard | Avoids responsibility; waits for direct instructions even when facing a clear operational problem. |
| 2 | Developing | Handles routine tasks but hesitates in non-routine situations and passes the problem to others. |
| 3 | Meets standard | Acts proactively within their knowledge and authority; tries logical alternatives to overcome obstacles. |
| 4 | Exceeds standard | Anticipates risks and takes preventive action; starts improvement projects beyond the job description. |
| 5 | Role model | Takes ownership in high-uncertainty crises; delivers lasting, scalable solutions with clear operational impact. |
Designing questions with the STAR method
The STAR method examines a candidate’s past Situation, the Task they took on, the Actions they performed and the Results they achieved. What matters is the chronological consistency of decisions and the concreteness of evidence, not polished statements.
| STAR step | Weak answer | Strong answer | Probing question |
|---|---|---|---|
| Situation | “A very important project was late because work had piled up.” | “Four weeks before migrating to a new e-commerce platform, we were two weeks behind because of a data integration error.” | “What did the delay cost the business, and how did stakeholders react?” |
| Task | “My manager asked me to solve the problem as soon as possible.” | “I took responsibility for resolving the integration issue, launching on the planned date and managing stakeholder communication.” | “Which metrics did you use to define success, and what was the biggest constraint?” |
| Action | “I organized emergency meetings and made everyone work overtime.” | “I postponed three non-essential features, set up daily 15-minute stand-ups to remove blockers and added resources to testing.” | “How did you choose the features to postpone, and how did you get the extra resources approved?” |
| Result | “We finished on time and management was happy.” | “We launched ahead of the revised schedule with a low error rate and reached the revenue target.” | “What would you do differently if you faced the same crisis today?” |
Competency-based interview question bank
Learning orientation
Question: “Tell me about a time you had to take on a task that required skills completely different from those you had.”
Probe: “How did you acquire the new skills, and how did you use the feedback you received?”
Business acumen
Question: “Give an example of using financial or commercial data to get senior management to approve a technical or operational idea.”
Probe: “Which indicators did you rely on, and how did you handle objections?”
Values alignment: speed and quality
Question: “Our organization values fast delivery over perfection. Tell me about a task you delivered even though you felt it was not entirely perfect.”
Probe: “What risks did you weigh, and how did you address the shortcomings later?”
Listening and leadership
Question: “Describe a time when active listening helped resolve a critical problem within a team or among stakeholders.”
Probe: “How did you show you were listening? Did you consider non-verbal cues as well as what was said?”
Candidate scorecards and calibration
A candidate scorecard records performance in weighted, role-specific competencies on a BARS scale after the interview and keeps decisions consistent across interviewers. An example weighting for a leadership role might be: manages ambiguity 25%, ensures accountability 20%, collaborates 20%, strategic mindset 20%, growth mindset 15%. Six rules help keep scorecards accurate:
- The 30-minute rule: Complete the scorecard within 30 minutes of the interview, before specific statements fade into general impressions.
- Independent scoring: Enter scores and written rationale before the joint debrief, so dominant voices do not drive groupthink.
- Separate competencies: Score each competency on its own; strength in one area should not mask gaps in another.
- Weighting: Give competencies that are critical to the role more weight than less critical ones.
- “Insufficient evidence” option: If the interview produced no concrete evidence for a competency, record it as insufficient rather than guessing a score.
- Regular calibration: Have the hiring team score shared interview recordings periodically and compare results to measure consistency between assessors.
Qulak’s video interview management supports this structure: every candidate answers the same competency questions, recordings can be reviewed by several assessors and scoring follows a shared rubric. AI can suggest rubric-based notes; the hiring decision stays with people.
Integrity in remote interviews
When competency interviews and language assessments run remotely, organizations should check that the person answering is the candidate and that answers are not prompted from outside. Useful questions to ask your process:
- Is the candidate’s identity verified, including a liveness check against photos or pre-recorded video?
- In written tasks, are tab switching, translation extensions and copy-paste restricted?
- In spoken interviews, are background voices or prompting from another person flagged for review?
For these needs, identity verification, locked browser, gaze and audio analysis are available through AI exam proctoring with QProctor, Qulak’s proctoring partner. AI flags suspicious moments with evidence; people review them and decide.
Build a structured interview process
Share your roles and competency model with the Qulak team; let’s set up question banks, rubrics and scorecards that every interviewer can use the same way.
Request a Demo